I intend to discuss two recent articles on the subject of thallus on jesus. Why we might have reason for doubt sheffield phoenix press, 2014 by richard carrier. Atheist hating on joe atwill by andre austin richard carrier, an atheist, is hating on the masterpiece works of joe atwill striking a blow at the mythology of the new testament. Richard carrier to winnipeg on his canadian speaking tour, august 19, 2017. Death and resurrection of the beloved son levenson. The notion of a risen jesus walking around on earth is a late invention first found in the gospels. But i did like carrier s kick the book across the room, after bart pointed out how jesus must have existed because marks gospel translated a line from psalm 22 into aramaic. He is trained in ancient history and classics, with a phd from columbia university an impressive credential. Caesars messiah is a 2005 book by joseph atwill, which argues that the new testament gospels were written as wartime propaganda by scholars connected to the roman imperial court of the flavian emperors. That is about as far from a christian religious view as you can get. Most are teachings of mysticism, as walking on water, for instance. Unfortunately, it is not a good example of his thesis, since it does not involve jesus being mapped onto titus as atwill s thesis proposes and the only distinct connection this story has with jesus is the name mary as the mother of an eaten child, and its connection to passover.
But mary unfortunately was one of the most common jewish female names being, as it was, the name of the sister of mosesone in four jewish women had the nameyou heard that rightone in four. However, carrier also agreed that the new testament has proroman aspects. I only had a half hour to speak and they started me off late, so i ran way over. The mythicist richard carrier similarly stated that all of atwills alleged parallels can be explained as either coincidences, mistranslations, or references to old testament sources or tropes. Go to almost any of the sites that come up i use a different browser tab to open the site. Richard carrier on his mythicist theory a tippling. However, i can see that my crack about prometheus books could be. According to atwill, their primary purpose in creating the religion was to control the spread of judaism and moderate its political virulence. Ramsey, so i am assuming this is not meant seriously but to mock ramseys fallacious. My atheism is based on findings more fundamental than anything to do with particular religions, but the arguments in favor of the christian worldview as opposed to any other are.
A longtime contributor to selfpublished philosophical web sites, including the secular web and freethought blogs, carrier has published a number of books and articles on philosophy and religion in classical antiquity, discussing the development of early christianity from a skeptical viewpoint, and concerning religion and morality in the modern world. Doing a quick search carrier s comment came up and i posted it in order to elicit a responsedefense from you or someone who is familiar with his work. Richard carrier entitled atwill s crankedup jesus, he makes no bones about how he feels. Unlike, say joseph atwill, our authors contend that paul was a real person. The creation of christianity and the 2000 year battle against the jews by alex gore the jews and gentiles have been at war with each other for a very long time and i believe that christianity came about as a way of dealing with the jews. For those who arent aware of him, richard carrier is a new atheist blogger who has a postgraduate degree in history from columbia and who, once upon a time, had a decent chance at an academic career. Why we might have reason for doubt by richard carrier.
There are many vastly more plausible deliberateinvention theories than atwills. Carrier phd is not only a historian but also a literary analyst and actually came up with his own parallel to josephus cannibal mary passage, which he claimed was an improvement over mine. But i would not describe that as undermining but as trying to fix a broken society. He lays out extensive research on the evidence for jesus and the origins of christianity and poses the key. Topics range from the historicity of jesus to how we do history anyways. On carriers prechristian jesus myth richard carrier is a freelance historian with a phd in ancient history from columbia university. Academics tend to not comment on crackpot theories as they offer little insight to historians. The biblical scholar joseph atwill claims that the story of jesus christ is a hoax designed to control the people. Conclusion of feedback on the atwillmurdock video about. In this atwill argues jesus is the invention of a roman emperor and. It seems ive done something to upset richard carrier. Earl doherty and the argument to ahistoricity 2002 richard carrier. I used to link to carriers articles rebutting the likes of acharya s and joseph atwill to.
Similarly, caesars messiah will rock our understanding of christian history as it reveals that jesus was a fictional character portrayed in four gospels written not by christians but romans. Why you should consider ordering the matrix revealed jon. Atwill says that the jesus story was designed by the roman empire to justify slavery and to pacify the citizens. In my book did jesus exist i speak of him as a smart scholar with bona fide credentials. The creation of christianity and the 2000 year battle. Atwills crankedup jesus by richard carrier on october 9, 20 548 comments joseph atwill is one of those crank mythers i often get conflated with. Most dairy cows are tied in place for their entire lives, unable even to walk around.
Even the most rudimentary factcheck would have brought this up. This collection of short essays serves to answer that question. Carrier didnt mention bart ehrmans strange claim that zeus was the father of zeus. Carrier goes on to call atwill a total crank, and says it is a bunch of pseudohistorical nonsense. Indeed, if he mentioned atwill even once it was in passing at best, and for the few.
I do, of course, heartily disagree with him on issues relating to the historical jesus. This flavian signature edition adds atwill s latest discoveries of numerous parallel events in sequence which ultimately reveal the identity of the true. I must admit though, richard, that i was hoping jerry would be rash enough to say that jesus was such a powerful heavy figure in history that his mere gravitational pull bent time and space around him erasing 10 years of history from 4bc to 6ad time dilation and bringing rome and syria into walking distance. When the article finally gets around to mentioning any names we find ehrman and aslan who dont question the historical existence of jesus, fitzgerald and atwill who are neither historians nor scholars and, of course, the lone but inevitable richard carrier.
Jesus stands not only for tiberius but also for a hypothetical zealot leader named eleazar, who also appears in the new testament as lazarus. For those who arent aware of him, richard carrier is a new atheist. On the historicity of jesus ohj is an exhaustive analysis of all extant evidence concerning the biblical jesus, ultimately offering sound reasons for doubt of jesus historicity. Atwill was just wiping his mouth when dr carrier walked up to him. Applying a bayesian criterion propounded in his foundational book proving history, carrier methodically breaks down contemporary historiographical assumptions, and. Why we might have reason for doubt carrier, richard on. Atwill s story doesnt seem to gel in any circle, atheistic or otherwise. It took atwill several years, apparently, to get up the gumption to make a reply, although to be fair, it may have been delayed because he was spending so much time looking for scholarly credibility, which is always in short supply for any. Mythicists like him make the job of serious scholars like me so much harder, because people see, hear, or read them and think their nonsense is what mythicism is. This does not address anything on dohertys website. In this profound and provocative work of scholarly detection, eminent biblical scholar robert eisenman introduces a startling theory about the identity of james the brother of jesus who was almost entirely marginalized in the new testament.
Richard carrier, in thallus and the darkness at christs death, journal of grecoroman christianity and judaism 8 20112012, 18591, argues that thallus did not mention jesus and that this is proven by eusebius who actually quotes him. Jesus ministry was turned into a parody of titus military war campaign against the jews from 6673ad written by. The death of richard carriers dying messiah religion at. Richard cevantis carrier born december 1, 1969 is an american author and activist, whose work focuses on empiricism, atheism, and the historicity of jesus. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Why we might have reason for doubt by carrier, richard isbn.
Atheists skeptical of atwills claim of a fabricated jesus. Atwill is a total crank, and his work should be ignored, indeed everywhere warned against as among the worst of mythicism, not representative of any serious argument that jesus didnt exist. Btw, besides denying that jesus of nazareth was a historical human, does carrier have a theory of how the nt and xianity as the imperial religion came to be, perhaps that is not some cranky conspiracy theory. James was a vegetarian, wore only linen clothing, bathed daily at dawn in cold water, and was a lifelong nazirite.
Richard carrier a mythicist, oh my not only daringly questions the existence of jesus, he argues that christianity more likely originated from beliefs of a mythical celestial being, born from jewish and hellenistic literature and then grew from an outcast jewish cult that believed in revelation, dreams and visions, rather than from the words. Tons of people keep circulating and then asking me about the world news daily story, newlyfound document holds eyewitness account of jesus performing miracle, claiming the first century pagan historian velleius paterculus recorded facts about jesus. He is arguably the most prominent proponent of the christ myth hypothesis, today, and one of the few historical scholars with actual qualifications in. Richard cevantis carrier is an american author and activist, whose work focuses on empiricism, atheism, and the historicity of jesus. Prior to reading your comment i hadnt heard of atwill. Carrier contrasts the most credible reconstruction of a historical jesus with the most credible theory of. To his credit, carrier was able to recognize that marys cannibalized son in josephus was, like jesus in the gospels, a human passover lamb. Why we might have reason for doubt kindle edition by carrier, richard. A longtime contributor to selfpublished philosophical web sites, including the secular web and freethought blogs, carrier has published a number of books and articles on philosophy and religion in classical antiquity, discussing the. But atwill s envisioned satire seems so complex as to be incoherent. Or rather, ive done something to get him to turn his nasal snark on me on behalf of his latest fawning minion.
Atwill, carotta and other scholars page 2 postflaviana. Fuller reply to richard carrier the bart ehrman blog. Brown has to burn three whole pages of dense text to argue that paradidonai has a primary meaning of hand over to the courts, which suggests some desperation, but in any case, i will repeat what i said. The article is full of statements which are plain stupid, such as. But if you really need more, snopes has you covered. According to atwill, the reader needs to comprehend perhaps the most complex literary satire ever written p. I like data and factual information if you like factual information then try and forget you ever watched this. Neil, have you looked into the work of richard carrier. Price, a jesus mythicist scholar, so that gives you at least one voice that is not a christian apologist. Loftus digs up the most amazing apologetics, and eviscerates them all.
Lena einhorn on the claudian christ theory by richard carrier on september 1, 2016 4 comments editor, physician and documentarian lena einhorn has written a book, a shift in time, arguing a new theory of the historical jesus. Lena einhorn on the claudian christ theory richard carrier. Atwills crankedup jesus richard carrier 27th june 2017by red johnsonleave a comment joseph atwill is one of those crank mythers i often get conflated with. Pick up your parcel at a time and place that suits you. Richard carrier on the historicity of jesus youtube. For an uptodate summary of everything see ehrman on historicity recap. Mythicists like him make the job of serious scholars like me so much harder, because people see, hear, or read them and think their nonsense is. The notion of a risen jesus walking around on earth is a late invention. Atwill is a total crank, and his work should be ignored, indeed everywhere warned against as among the worst of mythicism, not representative of any serious argument that jesus didnt exist richard carrier on joseph atwill hes similar to a selfprofessed prophet on this forum, cough cough. Richard carrier is one of the new breed of mythicists. Your second paragraph, in addition to being thoroughly uninformed, is also one gigantic non sequitur. So if you end up worshiping jesus what you really end up doing is worshiping caesar in disguise. Richard carrier on his mythicist theory by jonathan ms pearce may 22, 20 37 comments here is a good talk from richard carrier as it sets out his thesis from start to. Atwills crankedup jesus richard carrier 27th june 2017 by red johnson leave a comment joseph atwill is one of those crank mythers i often get conflated with.
Conclusion of feedback on the atwill murdock video about the roman conspiracy to invent christianity. Either way, walk the chain of evidence all the way back until you are at the first version of the story. On carriers prechristian jesus myth boxing pythagoras. This was the secular student alliance eastern national conference at ohio state university in columbus on 207. Religious scholar claims the story of jesus christ is fake. He says my emphasis that a historical jesus might be essential to the origins of. Challenging the existence of an historical jesus, a work by earl doherty canadian humanist publications.
285 1079 1116 1180 125 613 346 908 125 708 1080 1374 708 9 1261 1192 51 793 588 371 273 644 94 909 922 442 1081 863 88 1320 27 742 962 1111 659 1214 414 495